<time>2679_02:00:14,567 --> 02:00:16,667</time>
<s>啊所发问的这些问题来看</s>
<time>2680_02:00:17,367 --> 02:00:19,133</time>
<s>那么已经充分的反映出来</s>
<time>2681_02:00:19,833 --> 02:00:21,233</time>
<s>这个单就</s>
<time>2682_02:00:21,933 --> 02:00:25,067</time>
<s>州中医院正常的这个业务经营的这个</s>
<time>2683_02:00:25,433 --> 02:00:26,133</time>
<s>收入</s>
<time>2684_02:00:26,833 --> 02:00:28,933</time>
<s>都还不包括这个政府拔款</s>
<time>2685_02:00:29,267 --> 02:00:32,433</time>
<s>还有啊银行借款啊融资租赁等等这些</s>
<time>2686_02:00:33,133 --> 02:00:34,533</time>
<s>仅仅是这个</s>
<time>2687_02:00:35,567 --> 02:00:39,067</time>
<s>啊经正常经营的这个收入就已经能够</s>
<time>2688_02:00:39,767 --> 02:00:41,533</time>
<s>啊覆盖这个短期</s>
<time>2689_02:00:42,233 --> 02:00:44,333</time>
<s>短期的这个负债还有这个长期</s>
<time>2690_02:00:45,033 --> 02:00:46,767</time>
<s>医院基本建设的相关负债</s>
<time>2691_02:00:47,467 --> 02:00:49,567</time>
<s>所以我们认为这个鉴定意见是客观的</s>
<time>2692_02:00:49,933 --> 02:00:51,667</time>
<s>应当作为证据子以采信</s>
<time>2693_02:00:52,367 --> 02:00:54,133</time>
<s>鉴定人对刚公诉人</s>
<time>2694_02:00:54,467 --> 02:00:56,233</time>
<s>对你的出庭所做的一个</s>
<time>2695_02:00:56,933 --> 02:00:59,367</time>
<s>说明进行一个归纳念结和一个理解</s>
<time>2696_02:00:59,733 --> 02:01:01,833</time>
<s>说明你是否同意公诉人的这个说法我同意</s>
<time>2697_02:01:03,933 --> 02:01:04,267</time>
<s>好</s>
<time>2698_02:01:05,333 --> 02:01:05,667</time>
<s>好下面</s>
<time>2699_02:01:06,733 --> 02:01:07,433</time>
<s>鉴定人退庭</s>
<time>2700_02:01:14,067 --> 02:01:16,533</time>
<s>公诉人是否还有证据在法庭列举</s>
<time>2701_02:01:16,867 --> 02:01:18,967</time>
<s>本案的证据已经全部列举完毕</s>
<time>2702_02:01:22,833 --> 02:01:23,167</time>
<s>被告人韦光萍</s>
<time>2703_02:01:24,567 --> 02:01:25,967</time>
<s>你是否有证据向法庭提交</s>
<time>2704_02:01:26,667 --> 02:01:27,033</time>
<s>没有</s>
<time>2705_02:01:27,733 --> 02:01:29,467</time>
<s>辩护人是否有证据向法庭提交</s>
<time>2706_02:01:37,167 --> 02:01:37,867</time>
<s>有</s>
<time>2707_02:01:42,433 --> 02:01:44,533</time>
<s>辩护人这个向法庭提交</s>
<time>2708_02:01:45,567 --> 02:01:46,267</time>
<s>两组证据</s>
<time>2709_02:01:46,633 --> 02:01:49,767</time>
<s>在庭审庭前会议中间也把材料交给了</s>
<time>2710_02:01:50,133 --> 02:01:50,833</time>
<s>这个</s>
<time>2711_02:01:51,867 --> 02:01:53,267</time>
<s>法庭第一组呢是</s>
<time>2712_02:01:53,633 --> 02:01:53,967</time>
<s>关干</s>
<time>2713_02:01:54,333 --> 02:01:58,167</time>
<s>用文山州中医医院财务数据指标的</s>
<time>2714_02:01:58,867 --> 02:02:00,267</time>
<s>分析一共是四个表</s>
<time>2715_02:02:00,967 --> 02:02:02,367</time>
<s>第一个表就是经费自给率</s>
<time>2716_02:02:02,733 --> 02:02:03,767</time>
<s>刚我问的就是说</s>
<time>2717_02:02:04,467 --> 02:02:07,267</time>
<s>讲从2008年到2016年</s>
<time>2718_02:02:08,333 --> 02:02:12,533</time>
<s>整个医院的经营业务收入和业务支出</s>
<time>2719_02:02:13,233 --> 02:02:16,367</time>
<s>的平均率为0.93%</s>
<time>2720_02:02:16,733 --> 02:02:19,533</time>
<s>也就是医院是亏损状态</s>
<time>2721_02:02:19,867 --> 02:02:21,267</time>
<s>那么刚求鉴定人说</s>
<time>2722_02:02:21,633 --> 02:02:24,067</time>
<s>他用正常的收入就可以支什</s>
<time>2723_02:02:24,767 --> 02:02:26,167</time>
<s>医院的短期负债</s>
<time>2724_02:02:26,533 --> 02:02:28,267</time>
<s>这个说法完全是没根据的</s>
<time>2725_02:02:28,967 --> 02:02:30,033</time>
<s>第二个指标是</s>
<time>2726_02:02:30,733 --> 02:02:32,133</time>
<s>资产负债率</s>
<time>2727_02:02:32,833 --> 02:02:34,567</time>
<s>资产负债表统计的是</s>
<time>2728_02:02:35,633 --> 02:02:38,067</time>
<s>医院08年到16年的负债念额</s>
<time>2729_02:02:38,433 --> 02:02:39,833</time>
<s>和资产念额比</s>
<time>2730_02:02:40,533 --> 02:02:43,333</time>
<s>平均是69.7%</s>
<time>2731_02:02:43,667 --> 02:02:47,167</time>
<s>按照规定他不能大干和等干70%</s>
<time>2732_02:02:47,533 --> 02:02:49,633</time>
<s>这个指标念是讲他的在</s>
<time>2733_02:02:50,333 --> 02:02:52,067</time>
<s>医院的偿债能力方面</s>
<time>2734_02:02:52,433 --> 02:02:53,133</time>
<s>第三是呕</s>
<time>2735_02:02:54,167 --> 02:02:54,533</time>
<s>流动比率</s>
<time>2736_02:02:54,867 --> 02:02:57,667</time>
<s>是流动资产与流动负债的比率</s>
<time>2737_02:02:58,033 --> 02:03:00,467</time>
<s>按照相关规定他的比例是2比1</s>
<time>2738_02:03:00,833 --> 02:03:02,567</time>
<s>但是从医院的流动资产</s>
<time>2739_02:03:02,933 --> 02:03:03,967</time>
<s>流动负债相比来讲</s>
<time>2740_02:03:04,333 --> 02:03:06,767</time>
<s>打断一下辩护人现在是证举证啊</s>
<time>2741_02:03:07,133 --> 02:03:08,867</time>
<s>你不是这个是证吗</s>
<time>2742_02:03:09,233 --> 02:03:10,967</time>
<s>举证我作为说的啊</s>
<time>2743_02:03:11,333 --> 02:03:13,767</time>
<s>举证是你自己的一个分析的还是</s>
<time>2744_02:03:14,467 --> 02:03:16,567</time>
<s>是举证的吗是证据弄过</s>
<time>2745_02:03:17,267 --> 02:03:18,333</time>
<s>财务表反映出来</s>
<time>2746_02:03:18,667 --> 02:03:20,767</time>
<s>做编造的表格进行举证</s>
<time>2747_02:03:21,467 --> 02:03:22,167</time>
<s>道接说明这个</s>
<time>2748_02:03:22,533 --> 02:03:23,933</time>
<s>通过这一份好</s>
<time>2749_02:03:24,267 --> 02:03:24,967</time>
<s>这个是你的分析的话</s>
<time>2750_02:03:25,333 --> 02:03:26,733</time>
<s>你就在法律辩论的时候再说</s>
<time>2751_02:03:27,433 --> 02:03:28,467</time>
<s>现在我们说这个这个</s>
<time>2752_02:03:29,867 --> 02:03:31,267</time>
<s>啊这个信有什么</s>
<time>2753_02:03:31,967 --> 02:03:36,167</time>
<s>文山中中医院财务的数据四个表表明</s>
<time>2754_02:03:37,567 --> 02:03:38,967</time>
<s>文山州中医院</s>
<time>2755_02:03:39,667 --> 02:03:43,167</time>
<s>连基本的经营收入都是负债</s>
<time>2756_02:03:43,533 --> 02:03:45,633</time>
<s>邢是肯定需要举债的完了</s>
<time>2757_02:03:47,367 --> 02:03:50,167</time>
<s>第二个是证据目录是有几组证据</s>
<time>2758_02:03:50,533 --> 02:03:51,233</time>
<s>一共是</s>
<time>2759_02:03:53,333 --> 02:03:55,067</time>
<s>两组大证据是两大组</s>
<time>2760_02:03:55,433 --> 02:03:57,167</time>
<s>第一个第一组大证据是</s>
<time>2761_02:03:57,867 --> 02:04:01,033</time>
<s>一是2008年12月份文山州中医院整体迁建项目</s>
<time>2762_02:04:01,367 --> 02:04:03,133</time>
<s>可行新研究报告</s>
<time>2763_02:04:03,467 --> 02:04:04,867</time>
<s>部分章节及部分附件</s>
<time>2764_02:04:05,567 --> 02:04:06,967</time>
<s>他包含7三个附件</s>
<time>2765_02:04:07,333 --> 02:04:09,067</time>
<s>第一是文山州发改委</s>
<time>2766_02:04:10,467 --> 02:04:15,367</time>
<s>所发的文发改社会2007604号文</s>
<time>2767_02:04:16,067 --> 02:04:18,167</time>
<s>第二是文山州卫生局</s>
<time>2768_02:04:19,233 --> 02:04:22,367</time>
<s>发的文卫发2008第107号</s>
<time>2769_02:04:23,067 --> 02:04:25,533</time>
<s>第三个是文山州人民政府</s>
<time>2770_02:04:26,567 --> 02:04:27,267</time>
<s>第十二届州政府</s>
<time>2771_02:04:27,633 --> 02:04:29,367</time>
<s>第十八次常务会议纪要</s>
<time>2772_02:04:30,067 --> 02:04:31,467</time>
<s>是2018年的7月7日</s>
<time>2773_02:04:33,933 --> 02:04:37,767</time>
<s>第二块是2009年12月文山州中医院利用</s>
<time>2774_02:04:38,833 --> 02:04:39,167</time>
<s>啦啦</s>
<time>2775_02:04:39,867 --> 02:04:42,667</time>
<s>国外政府的贷款购置设备的项目</s>
<time>2776_02:04:43,033 --> 02:04:45,467</time>
<s>建议书部分章节这部分附件</s>
<time>2777_02:04:46,167 --> 02:04:47,933</time>
<s>第一是文山州人民政府所发</s>
<time>2778_02:04:48,267 --> 02:04:51,767</time>
<s>的文政府200999号</s>
<time>2779_02:04:52,133 --> 02:04:57,367</time>
<s>文山州财政局所发的文财外200953号</s>
<time>2780_02:04:58,067 --> 02:05:00,533</time>
<s>辩护人具体的因为文件很多</s>
<time>2781_02:05:00,867 --> 02:05:01,933</time>
<s>就因为庭前会议</s>
<time>2782_02:05:02,267 --> 02:05:03,667</time>
<s>都已经提交给公诉人看过了</s>
<time>2783_02:05:04,033 --> 02:05:05,767</time>
<s>就不具体念这个文件名了</s>
<time>2784_02:05:06,133 --> 02:05:07,533</time>
<s>好吧你就说一下啊</s>
<time>2785_02:05:07,867 --> 02:05:09,267</time>
<s>主要是后面问题他要证</s>
<time>2786_02:05:09,633 --> 02:05:12,433</time>
<s>他要证实的问题是</s>
<time>2787_02:05:13,133 --> 02:05:15,933</time>
<s>文山州中医医院整体搬迁建设项目</s>
<time>2788_02:05:16,267 --> 02:05:18,733</time>
<s>系文山州人民政府及相关部门</s>
<time>2789_02:05:19,067 --> 02:05:20,467</time>
<s>批准实施的</s>
<time>2790_02:05:21,167 --> 02:05:21,867</time>
<s>第二要证实文山州</s>
<time>2791_02:05:22,233 --> 02:05:24,333</time>
<s>中医院整体搬迁建设项目的经费</s>
<time>2792_02:05:24,667 --> 02:05:26,767</time>
<s>估算出国家审议</s>
<time>2793_02:05:27,467 --> 02:05:29,233</time>
<s>补补助1,500万</s>
<time>2794_02:05:29,933 --> 02:05:31,333</time>
<s>再置换资金3100万</s>
<time>2795_02:05:32,033 --> 02:05:34,467</time>
<s>第二期投资3：400万是通过银行贷款</s>
<time>2796_02:05:35,167 --> 02:05:36,933</time>
<s>需要的资金全部是自筹</s>
<time>2797_02:05:37,967 --> 02:05:41,133</time>
<s>第三是文山州中医院利用国外政府的</s>
<time>2798_02:05:41,467 --> 02:05:43,233</time>
<s>所购置的嗯</s>
<time>2799_02:05:43,567 --> 02:05:45,667</time>
<s>设备是经过文山州人民政府</s>
<time>2800_02:05:46,033 --> 02:05:49,167</time>
<s>相关部门批准实施的大概是490万欧</s>
<time>2801_02:05:50,233 --> 02:05:51,267</time>
<s>欧欧元的</s>
<time>2802_02:05:52,333 --> 02:05:53,033</time>
<s>第四是文山州</s>
<time>2803_02:05:54,433 --> 02:05:56,867</time>
<s>中医院利用国外政府的其设备的</s>
<time>2804_02:05:57,933 --> 02:06:01,767</time>
<s>还款什息的担保是由州财政局出面的</s>
<time>2805_02:06:02,133 --> 02:06:04,233</time>
<s>第五是为了提高文山州中医院</s>
<time>2806_02:06:04,567 --> 02:06:05,633</time>
<s>三甲医院的</s>
<time>2807_02:06:06,333 --> 02:06:07,367</time>
<s>水平硬件水平</s>
<time>2808_02:06:08,067 --> 02:06:09,833</time>
<s>所以呢通过租赁融资</s>
<time>2809_02:06:10,167 --> 02:06:12,633</time>
<s>租赁方式所配置的医院的设备是</s>
<time>2810_02:06:13,333 --> 02:06:15,767</time>
<s>一亿三千五百七十万元的设备</s>
<time>2811_02:06:16,833 --> 02:06:19,633</time>
<s>第六个是证明文山州中医院从2008年</s>
<time>2812_02:06:19,967 --> 02:06:21,033</time>
<s>拥有固定资产</s>
<time>2813_02:06:21,733 --> 02:06:25,567</time>
<s>3098.39万元的三级Z等医院</s>
<time>2814_02:06:25,933 --> 02:06:28,367</time>
<s>截止到2007年12月底</s>
<time>2815_02:06:28,733 --> 02:06:36,767</time>
<s>拥有您资产553,398:000多元的三甲医院</s>
<time>2816_02:06:38,533 --> 02:06:39,567</time>
<s>他是一个医院的变化过程</s>
<time>2817_02:06:39,933 --> 02:06:40,967</time>
<s>第二组中间所证明的</s>
<time>2818_02:06:41,333 --> 02:06:42,733</time>
<s>他一共是七份林料</s>
<time>2819_02:06:43,433 --> 02:06:45,167</time>
<s>就是相关的政府改革</s>
<time>2820_02:06:45,533 --> 02:06:46,567</time>
<s>这些料我就不念了</s>
<time>2821_02:06:46,933 --> 02:06:50,433</time>
<s>他从这个里边我们是要进行证实是</s>
<time>2822_02:06:51,133 --> 02:06:52,533</time>
<s>第一从中央到地方</s>
<time>2823_02:06:52,867 --> 02:06:54,633</time>
<s>鼓励引导社会资本</s>
<time>2824_02:06:54,967 --> 02:06:58,467</time>
<s>以多种方式参与公立医院的改制</s>
<time>2825_02:06:58,833 --> 02:07:00,567</time>
<s>重组投资和办医</s>
<time>2826_02:07:01,267 --> 02:07:03,367</time>
<s>第二是证明文山州中医院在整体</s>
<time>2827_02:07:04,067 --> 02:07:04,767</time>
<s>搬建设</s>
<time>2828_02:07:05,467 --> 02:07:08,967</time>
<s>及购置要设备工程中间自筹资金</s>
<time>2829_02:07:09,333 --> 02:07:10,033</time>
<s>所自筹</s>
<time>2830_02:07:10,733 --> 02:07:11,433</time>
<s>资金的行为</s>
<time>2831_02:07:11,767 --> 02:07:13,533</time>
<s>是经过文山州人民政府地方</s>
<time>2832_02:07:13,867 --> 02:07:14,567</time>
<s>部门批准的</s>
<time>2833_02:07:14,933 --> 02:07:15,633</time>
<s>是自筹</s>
<time>2834_02:07:16,667 --> 02:07:19,133</time>
<s>第三中医院在整体迁建过程</s>
<time>2835_02:07:19,467 --> 02:07:21,933</time>
<s>项目推进中间构设备过程中间的行为</s>
<time>2836_02:07:22,267 --> 02:07:25,067</time>
<s>是经过医院院务会议决定的</s>
<time>2837_02:07:25,433 --> 02:07:26,133</time>
<s>并向</s>
<time>2838_02:07:27,167 --> 02:07:28,933</time>
<s>相关部门进行过报备</s>
<time>2839_02:07:29,967 --> 02:07:31,367</time>
<s>第四是通过</s>
<time>2840_02:07:32,067 --> 02:07:35,567</time>
<s>被告人们所记的日记和文山州</s>
<time>2841_02:07:36,967 --> 02:07:39,067</time>
<s>卫计委的2018年9号批复</s>
<time>2842_02:07:39,433 --> 02:07:40,833</time>
<s>可以证实文山州中医院</s>
<time>2843_02:07:41,867 --> 02:07:43,267</time>
<s>整体迁建项目</s>
<time>2844_02:07:43,633 --> 02:07:46,767</time>
<s>购置医疗设备过程中自筹资金</s>
<time>2845_02:07:47,133 --> 02:07:47,833</time>
<s>和融资的行为</s>
<time>2846_02:07:48,167 --> 02:07:51,333</time>
<s>并非韦光萍个人的擅自行为</s>
<time>2847_02:07:52,367 --> 02:07:55,167</time>
<s>综上所述公诉机关指控韦光萍的</s>
<time>2848_02:07:55,533 --> 02:07:56,933</time>
<s>违反规定擅自决定</s>
<time>2849_02:07:57,633 --> 02:07:59,033</time>
<s>向民间</s>
<time>2850_02:07:59,733 --> 02:08:02,867</time>
<s>融资涉嫌国有事业滥用职权罪</s>
<time>2851_02:08:03,233 --> 02:08:04,633</time>
<s>给国家利盆造成损失的</s>
<time>2852_02:08:05,333 --> 02:08:07,767</time>
<s>有背事实法律指控不成立完了谢谢</s>
<time>2853_02:08:09,867 --> 02:08:11,633</time>
<s>啊有公诉人对辩护人所</s>
<time>2854_02:08:12,333 --> 02:08:13,733</time>
<s>列举的证据发表质证意见</s>
<time>2855_02:08:15,467 --> 02:08:15,833</time>
<s>吧</s>
<time>2856_02:08:16,533 --> 02:08:17,233</time>
<s>针对这个</s>
<time>2857_02:08:17,933 --> 02:08:19,667</time>
<s>辩护人所提交的这个相关证据</s>
<time>2858_02:08:20,733 --> 02:08:22,833</time>
<s>邢么公诉人发表这个相关质证意见</s>
<time>2859_02:08:23,167 --> 02:08:23,867</time>
<s>那么首先第一点</s>
<time>2860_02:08:24,933 --> 02:08:27,733</time>
<s>对干相关啊辩护人提交的相关证据</s>
<time>2861_02:08:28,067 --> 02:08:29,467</time>
<s>邢么均为这个复印件</s>
<time>2862_02:08:30,533 --> 02:08:33,333</time>
<s>邢么其中除了已经公开的这个相关</s>
<time>2863_02:08:33,667 --> 02:08:34,033</time>
<s>医改的有</s>
<time>2864_02:08:34,367 --> 02:08:35,767</time>
<s>证据需要看吗</s>
<time>2865_02:08:37,533 --> 02:08:39,267</time>
<s>原原件需要看吗</s>
<time>2866_02:08:39,967 --> 02:08:43,833</time>
<s>辩护人这个先由公诉人发表完质证意见</s>
<time>2867_02:08:46,267 --> 02:08:48,367</time>
<s>因为之前庭前会议提交的是这个复印件</s>
<time>2868_02:08:49,767 --> 02:08:52,233</time>
<s>你庭后把原件提交给法庭好吗</s>
<time>2869_02:08:52,933 --> 02:08:54,333</time>
<s>啊公人继续发表意见</s>
<time>2870_02:08:55,367 --> 02:08:56,767</time>
<s>公诉人因为看</s>
<time>2871_02:08:57,133 --> 02:08:57,833</time>
<s>庭前会议上</s>
<time>2872_02:08:58,167 --> 02:08:59,933</time>
<s>提交给公诉人的都是复印件</s>
<time>2873_02:09:00,267 --> 02:09:02,033</time>
<s>所以针对这个证据</s>
<time>2874_02:09:02,367 --> 02:09:04,133</time>
<s>公诉人要发表这个质证意见</s>
<time>2875_02:09:05,167 --> 02:09:05,867</time>
<s>邢么就是说啊</s>
<time>2876_02:09:06,233 --> 02:09:08,667</time>
<s>除了这个公开的医改这个情况之外</s>
<time>2877_02:09:09,367 --> 02:09:11,467</time>
<s>邢么从证据的形式上邢么来源不清</s>
<time>2878_02:09:12,167 --> 02:09:13,567</time>
<s>那么刚求辩护人也提到了</s>
<time>2879_02:09:13,933 --> 02:09:14,633</time>
<s>说是有原件</s>
<time>2880_02:09:15,333 --> 02:09:17,767</time>
<s>那么可以向法庭提供相应的原件</s>
<time>2881_02:09:18,467 --> 02:09:21,633</time>
<s>如果复印件与原件内容相符的话</s>
<time>2882_02:09:21,967 --> 02:09:23,733</time>
<s>那么我们认可这个证据的来源</s>
<time>2883_02:09:24,433 --> 02:09:26,167</time>
<s>如果啊没有原件</s>
<time>2884_02:09:26,533 --> 02:09:29,333</time>
<s>邢那么请出啊这个明确这个来源情况</s>
<time>2885_02:09:29,667 --> 02:09:31,433</time>
<s>以确保这个证据的客观真实性</s>
<time>2886_02:09:32,467 --> 02:09:33,167</time>
<s>邢么第二一点</s>
<time>2887_02:09:33,867 --> 02:09:34,233</time>
<s>那么就是说</s>
<time>2888_02:09:34,567 --> 02:09:34,933</time>
<s>在肯定</s>
<time>2889_02:09:35,267 --> 02:09:38,067</time>
<s>证据内容客观真实性的这个前提下</s>
<time>2890_02:09:38,767 --> 02:09:40,167</time>
<s>邢么以上的这个证据</s>
<time>2891_02:09:40,867 --> 02:09:42,267</time>
<s>我们认为是不能够呢</s>
<time>2892_02:09:42,967 --> 02:09:45,067</time>
<s>得出这个辩护人所提到的这个</s>
<time>2893_02:09:45,433 --> 02:09:46,133</time>
<s>证明观点</s>
<time>2894_02:09:46,467 --> 02:09:47,867</time>
<s>反而是印证了起诉</s>
<time>2895_02:09:48,233 --> 02:09:49,267</time>
<s>指控的相关犯罪事实</s>
<time>2896_02:09:50,333 --> 02:09:51,033</time>
<s>邢么首先第一点</s>
<time>2897_02:09:51,733 --> 02:09:53,467</time>
<s>啊从提交的这个相关的这个</s>
<time>2898_02:09:54,533 --> 02:09:56,267</time>
<s>啦刚求辩护人提交的四个表</s>
<time>2899_02:09:56,967 --> 02:09:58,033</time>
<s>就是他自己啊</s>
<time>2900_02:09:58,367 --> 02:10:00,833</time>
<s>通过自己的这个计算然后得啊</s>
<time>2901_02:10:01,167 --> 02:10:01,533</time>
<s>说明这个</s>
<time>2902_02:10:02,233 --> 02:10:03,967</time>
<s>特别是这个资金自给率啊</s>
<time>2903_02:10:04,333 --> 02:10:05,733</time>
<s>说明这个州中医院</s>
<time>2904_02:10:06,433 --> 02:10:07,833</time>
<s>啊支大干收</s>
<time>2905_02:10:08,533 --> 02:10:10,633</time>
<s>邢么收支不平衡有举债的必要</s>
<time>2906_02:10:11,333 --> 02:10:12,367</time>
<s>邢那么公诉人认为就是说</s>
<time>2907_02:10:13,433 --> 02:10:15,167</time>
<s>辩护人提取相关数据</s>
<time>2908_02:10:15,533 --> 02:10:17,967</time>
<s>邢么实际上也是根据这个资产负债表</s>
<time>2909_02:10:18,333 --> 02:10:18,667</time>
<s>还有这个</s>
<time>2910_02:10:19,367 --> 02:10:20,767</time>
<s>啊卷内所提供的这个</s>
<time>2911_02:10:21,467 --> 02:10:22,867</time>
<s>几年的这个预决算</s>
<time>2912_02:10:23,567 --> 02:10:24,633</time>
<s>邢么我们认为就是说</s>
<time>2913_02:10:25,333 --> 02:10:27,767</time>
<s>实际上他整个收和支</s>
<time>2914_02:10:28,133 --> 02:10:29,533</time>
<s>他是一个流动性的</s>
<time>2915_02:10:30,233 --> 02:10:31,267</time>
<s>是流动的概念</s>
<time>2916_02:10:31,967 --> 02:10:34,433</time>
<s>邢么所呕辩护人计算的这个</s>
<time>2917_02:10:34,767 --> 02:10:38,267</time>
<s>都是用这个当年的念收入和您支出</s>
<time>2918_02:10:38,967 --> 02:10:39,667</time>
<s>来进行一个比较</s>
<time>2919_02:10:40,367 --> 02:10:42,467</time>
<s>得出来这个当年的收支不平衡</s>
<time>2920_02:10:43,533 --> 02:10:43,867</time>
<s>但是我们认为</s>
<time>2921_02:10:44,233 --> 02:10:45,633</time>
<s>他这个是一个流动性的东西</s>
<time>2922_02:10:46,333 --> 02:10:49,133</time>
<s>你比如说我现在借钱可能我啊要还钱</s>
<time>2923_02:10:49,467 --> 02:10:50,533</time>
<s>但是医院的这个经营收入</s>
<time>2924_02:10:50,867 --> 02:10:51,567</time>
<s>也是流动性的</s>
<time>2925_02:10:52,967 --> 02:10:54,733</time>
<s>我这一段时间的这个经营的这个</s>
<time>2926_02:10:55,067 --> 02:10:57,867</time>
<s>呢收入是不是对这一部分的这个呢</s>
<time>2927_02:10:58,233 --> 02:10:59,267</time>
<s>这个债务就能够</s>
<time>2928_02:11:00,333 --> 02:11:02,433</time>
<s>支什所以我们认为这个是流动性的</s>
<time>2929_02:11:02,767 --> 02:11:05,233</time>
<s>而且从这个报表当中提取的数据的</s>
<time>2930_02:11:05,567 --> 02:11:06,967</time>
<s>其中支出的部分</s>
<time>2931_02:11:08,033 --> 02:11:10,133</time>
<s>邢么在后面举债之后的这几年</s>
<time>2932_02:11:11,167 --> 02:11:13,633</time>
<s>邢么实际上他支出的部分已经包含了</s>
<time>2933_02:11:14,333 --> 02:11:15,733</time>
<s>高额利息的支出部分</s>
<time>2934_02:11:17,133 --> 02:11:18,867</time>
<s>就是他对外举债之后要支什</s>
<time>2935_02:11:19,567 --> 02:11:20,267</time>
<s>这些高利息</s>
<time>2936_02:11:20,967 --> 02:11:21,667</time>
<s>这个支出部分</s>
<time>2937_02:11:22,033 --> 02:11:23,767</time>
<s>就已经反映在了这个念支出部分</s>
<time>2938_02:11:24,467 --> 02:11:25,867</time>
<s>所以他计算出来的这个</s>
<time>2939_02:11:26,233 --> 02:11:27,633</time>
<s>当然就肯定的是</s>
<time>2940_02:11:27,967 --> 02:11:28,333</time>
<s>支</s>
<time>2941_02:11:29,033 --> 02:11:31,467</time>
<s>大收但是这个是已经在这个</s>
<time>2942_02:11:32,167 --> 02:11:33,933</time>
<s>啊包含了这个高额支出的情况下</s>
<time>2943_02:11:34,267 --> 02:11:35,333</time>
<s>所得出来的这个结论</s>
<time>2944_02:11:35,667 --> 02:11:36,367</time>
<s>所以我们认为这个</s>
<time>2945_02:11:37,067 --> 02:11:39,167</time>
<s>呕得出的这个结论是呢</s>
<time>2946_02:11:39,867 --> 02:11:40,233</time>
<s>不客观的</s>
<time>2947_02:11:41,267 --> 02:11:42,333</time>
<s>然后第二点</s>
<time>2948_02:11:42,667 --> 02:11:44,767</time>
<s>邢么从相关的这个医改的规定来看</s>
<time>2949_02:11:45,467 --> 02:11:46,867</time>
<s>邢么刚求辩护人员也提到了</s>
<time>2950_02:11:47,233 --> 02:11:49,667</time>
<s>鼓励社会资本资本进入这个医院</s>
<time>2951_02:11:51,433 --> 02:11:53,867</time>
<s>但是他其中规定就是不得改变这个</s>
<time>2952_02:11:54,567 --> 02:11:56,667</time>
<s>非盈利性质并且要严格控制规模</s>
<time>2953_02:11:57,733 --> 02:11:58,767</time>
<s>这个从09年</s>
<time>2954_02:11:59,133 --> 02:12:00,167</time>
<s>中共中央和国务院</s>
<time>2955_02:12:00,533 --> 02:12:01,567</time>
<s>关干医改的指导意见当中</s>
<time>2956_02:12:01,933 --> 02:12:02,633</time>
<s>也明确</s>
<time>2957_02:12:03,667 --> 02:12:06,833</time>
<s>要严格控制公立医院的建设规模</s>
<time>2958_02:12:07,533 --> 02:12:09,267</time>
<s>标准和贷款的行为</s>
<time>2959_02:12:11,033 --> 02:12:11,367</time>
<s>第二一点</s>
<time>2960_02:12:12,433 --> 02:12:14,167</time>
<s>关干这个州中医院的迁建</s>
<time>2961_02:12:14,533 --> 02:12:16,633</time>
<s>包括向奥地利政府啊贷款</s>
<time>2962_02:12:17,333 --> 02:12:17,667</time>
<s>还有这个</s>
<time>2963_02:12:18,733 --> 02:12:20,133</time>
<s>融资租赁购买设备</s>
<time>2964_02:12:20,467 --> 02:12:22,933</time>
<s>引入康美公司合作等等等等</s>
<time>2965_02:12:23,967 --> 02:12:25,733</time>
<s>相应的这些都可以看出</s>
<time>2966_02:12:26,433 --> 02:12:27,833</time>
<s>医院的重大事项</s>
<time>2967_02:12:28,533 --> 02:12:30,967</time>
<s>都需要向有关部门请示和批复</s>
<time>2968_02:12:32,033 --> 02:12:33,767</time>
<s>包括像这个融资租赁</s>
<time>2969_02:12:34,833 --> 02:12:35,167</time>
<s>融资贷款</s>
<time>2970_02:12:36,233 --> 02:12:36,933</time>
<s>都需要批付</s>
<time>2971_02:12:37,633 --> 02:12:39,367</time>
<s>并非可以自行决定</s>
<time>2972_02:12:40,067 --> 02:12:42,167</time>
<s>因此州中医院向民间借贷</s>
<time>2973_02:12:42,867 --> 02:12:45,667</time>
<s>同样我们认为也应当经有关部门批复</s>
<time>2974_02:12:46,733 --> 02:12:47,433</time>
<s>审批这个</s>
<time>2975_02:12:48,133 --> 02:12:49,533</time>
<s>在这个医院的务制度当中</s>
<time>2976_02:12:49,867 --> 02:12:50,567</time>
<s>也有明确规定</s>
<time>2977_02:12:51,633 --> 02:12:51,967</time>
<s>第三一点</s>
<time>2978_02:12:52,667 --> 02:12:54,433</time>
<s>从韦光萍自己的会议记录当中</s>
<time>2979_02:12:54,767 --> 02:12:55,833</time>
<s>我们也可以看得出来</s>
<time>2980_02:12:56,867 --> 02:12:59,333</time>
<s>他自己的会议当中也没有记录</s>
<time>2981_02:13:00,033 --> 02:13:03,167</time>
<s>关干啊其所提到的向民间借贷啊</s>
<time>2982_02:13:03,533 --> 02:13:05,267</time>
<s>召开院办公会的这个记录</s>
<time>2983_02:13:05,633 --> 02:13:06,667</time>
<s>在他自己的这个</s>
<time>2984_02:13:07,367 --> 02:13:09,467</time>
<s>啊记笔记本里面也没有记录</s>
<time>2985_02:13:10,867 --> 02:13:11,933</time>
<s>甚至为了应什检查</s>
<time>2986_02:13:12,267 --> 02:13:12,967</time>
<s>他们补的这个</s>
<time>2987_02:13:13,333 --> 02:13:16,133</time>
<s>2010年10月20号这个会议纪要啊</s>
<time>2988_02:13:16,467 --> 02:13:18,233</time>
<s>会议这个纪要当天</s>
<time>2989_02:13:18,933 --> 02:13:21,033</time>
<s>10月20号的这个会议记记录</s>
<time>2990_02:13:21,367 --> 02:13:22,767</time>
<s>在他自己的笔记本当中</s>
<time>2991_02:13:23,133 --> 02:13:24,167</time>
<s>也没有这一次记录</s>
<time>2992_02:13:25,233 --> 02:13:27,333</time>
<s>啊因此我们认为就是啊</s>
<time>2993_02:13:27,667 --> 02:13:28,367</time>
<s>刚好就是验证了</s>
<time>2994_02:13:28,733 --> 02:13:31,533</time>
<s>就说没有相应的这个会议计论这个</s>
<time>2995_02:13:31,867 --> 02:13:32,567</time>
<s>这个情况啊</s>
<time>2996_02:13:32,933 --> 02:13:33,633</time>
<s>就做这个质证</s>
<time>2997_02:13:35,733 --> 02:13:37,133</time>
<s>啊辩护人是否还有证据</s>
<time>2998_02:13:39,233 --> 02:13:40,267</time>
<s>就把刚戈所</s>
<time>2999_02:13:41,333 --> 02:13:43,433</time>
<s>质得证据提交法法庭</s>
<time>3000_02:13:49,733 --> 02:13:52,167</time>
<s>庭后再提交了辩护人啊</s>
<time>3001_02:13:52,867 --> 02:13:54,967</time>
<s>庭后提交刚刚公诉人已经说了如果原件</s>
<time>3002_02:13:55,667 --> 02:13:56,033</time>
<s>这个复印件</s>
<time>3003_02:13:56,733 --> 02:13:57,767</time>
<s>这个核对无异议的</s>
<time>3004_02:13:58,133 --> 02:13:59,867</time>
<s>对证据来源没有没有筝议好吧好</s>
<time>3005_02:14:00,933 --> 02:14:02,667</time>
<s>其他的没有其他没有了是吧</s>
<time>3006_02:14:17,033 --> 02:14:18,433</time>
<s>公诉人当庭列举的证据</s>
<time>3007_02:14:18,767 --> 02:14:21,567</time>
<s>对干被告人和辩护人没有提出异议的</s>
<time>3008_02:14:21,933 --> 02:14:24,733</time>
<s>本庭子以采纳作为本案的定案依据</s>
<time>3009_02:14:25,433 --> 02:14:27,167</time>
<s>对干提出意义的</s>
<time>3010_02:14:27,867 --> 02:14:28,567</time>
<s>有筝议的证据</s>
<time>3011_02:14:28,933 --> 02:14:31,367</time>
<s>以及辩护人当庭提交的这些证据</s>
<time>3012_02:14:31,733 --> 02:14:33,133</time>
<s>有筝议的证据</s>
<time>3013_02:14:33,467 --> 02:14:37,333</time>
<s>法庭将综合全案这事实证据进行分析</s>
<time>3014_02:14:37,667 --> 02:14:39,067</time>
<s>是否作为定案例依据</s>
<time>3015_02:14:39,767 --> 02:14:40,467</time>
<s>再做确认</s>
<time>3016_02:14:41,167 --> 02:14:43,967</time>
<s>法庭调查结束下面进行法庭辩论</s>
<time>3017_02:14:44,333 --> 02:14:46,067</time>
<s>先由由公诉人发表公诉意见</s>
<time>3018_02:14:47,133 --> 02:14:48,167</time>
<s>审判长审翔员</s>
<time>3019_02:14:48,867 --> 02:14:50,267</time>
<s>根据刑事诉讼法的相关规定</s>
<time>3020_02:14:50,633 --> 02:14:51,333</time>
<s>我们受本院指派</s>
<time>3021_02:14:51,667 --> 02:14:54,133</time>
<s>以国家公诉公诉人的身份出席法庭</s>
<time>3022_02:14:54,467 --> 02:14:54,833</time>
<s>支持公诉</s>
<time>3023_02:14:55,533 --> 02:14:57,633</time>
<s>并依法对刑事诉讼实施法律监督</s>
<time>3024_02:14:58,333 --> 02:15:00,067</time>
<s>现在本案事实证据及法律适用</s>
<time>3025_02:15:00,433 --> 02:15:01,467</time>
<s>发表以下公所意见</s>
<time>3026_02:15:02,533 --> 02:15:03,933</time>
<s>在刚求的法庭调查当中</s>
<time>3027_02:15:04,267 --> 02:15:06,033</time>
<s>公诉人通过对被告人的讯</s>
<time>3028_02:15:06,367 --> 02:15:07,767</time>
<s>当庭宣读证人证言</s>
<time>3029_02:15:08,133 --> 02:15:09,167</time>
<s>被告人的供迷与辩解</s>
<time>3030_02:15:09,867 --> 02:15:10,233</time>
<s>鉴定意见</s>
<time>3031_02:15:10,933 --> 02:15:12,333</time>
<s>并出示了相关书证</s>
<time>3032_02:15:13,033 --> 02:15:16,167</time>
<s>同时对这个鉴定人出庭进行了这个</s>
<time>3033_02:15:17,233 --> 02:15:19,667</time>
<s>啊发问经过当庭的举证质证</s>
<time>3034_02:15:20,033 --> 02:15:21,433</time>
<s>全面反映本案的事实</s>
<time>3035_02:15:22,133 --> 02:15:24,233</time>
<s>充分证明本院起诉书指控被告人韦光萍</s>
<time>3036_02:15:24,567 --> 02:15:26,333</time>
<s>构成受贿罪</s>
<time>3037_02:15:26,667 --> 02:15:27,733</time>
<s>国有事业单位</s>
<time>3038_02:15:28,067 --> 02:15:29,833</time>
<s>人员滥用职权罪的事实清楚</s>
<time>3039_02:15:30,167 --> 02:15:30,867</time>
<s>证据确实充分</s>
<time>3040_02:15:32,267 --> 02:15:34,733</time>
<s>一被告人韦光萍的行为构成受贿罪</s>
<time>3041_02:15:35,767 --> 02:15:37,867</time>
<s>鉴干被告人在庭前会议及庭审中</s>
<time>3042_02:15:38,233 --> 02:15:39,633</time>
<s>均表示对受贿罪</s>
<time>3043_02:15:39,967 --> 02:15:40,333</time>
<s>有意义</s>
<time>3044_02:15:40,667 --> 02:15:43,133</time>
<s>邢么公诉人不再展开做详细论述</s>
<time>3045_02:15:43,833 --> 02:15:44,533</time>
<s>邢么本案当中</s>
<time>3046_02:15:44,867 --> 02:15:45,233</time>
<s>被告人</s>
<time>3047_02:15:45,567 --> 02:15:47,667</time>
<s>韦光平在担任州中医院院长期间</s>
<time>3048_02:15:48,367 --> 02:15:49,767</time>
<s>明知吴美容段建光</s>
<time>3049_02:15:50,133 --> 02:15:51,167</time>
<s>等11名行贿人</s>
<time>3050_02:15:51,533 --> 02:15:53,633</time>
<s>所在公司与医院存在业务往来</s>
<time>3051_02:15:54,333 --> 02:15:55,367</time>
<s>为与其搞好关系</s>
<time>3052_02:15:55,733 --> 02:15:58,167</time>
<s>在相关业务和资金拨什等给子关照</s>
<time>3053_02:15:58,533 --> 02:16:00,967</time>
<s>收受现金共计166.5万元</s>
<time>3054_02:16:01,667 --> 02:16:03,067</time>
<s>侵犯7国家工作人员</s>
<time>3055_02:16:03,433 --> 02:16:05,167</time>
<s>职务行为廉洁性和不可收买性</s>
<time>3056_02:16:05,867 --> 02:16:06,933</time>
<s>其行为符合</s>
<time>3057_02:16:07,633 --> 02:16:08,667</time>
<s>受贿罪的构成要件</s>
<time>3058_02:16:09,367 --> 02:16:11,133</time>
<s>二被告人韦光萍的行为</s>
<time>3059_02:16:11,467 --> 02:16:14,267</time>
<s>构成国有事业单位人员滥用职权罪</s>
<time>3060_02:16:14,967 --> 02:16:16,733</time>
<s>刑法第168条规定</s>
<time>3061_02:16:17,433 --> 02:16:18,133</time>
<s>国有事业单位</s>
<time>3062_02:16:18,467 --> 02:16:19,533</time>
<s>工作人员盟用职权</s>
<time>3063_02:16:19,867 --> 02:16:22,333</time>
<s>致使国家利盆遭受重大损失的行为</s>
<time>3064_02:16:23,033 --> 02:16:25,467</time>
<s>是国有事业单位人员滥用职权罪</s>
<time>3065_02:16:26,867 --> 02:16:28,267</time>
<s>邢么本案是否构成犯罪</s>
<time>3066_02:16:28,633 --> 02:16:30,367</time>
<s>主要从两个方面进行分析</s>
<time>3067_02:16:31,067 --> 02:16:33,533</time>
<s>一是被告人为韦光萍否滥用职权</s>
<time>3068_02:16:34,233 --> 02:16:35,267</time>
<s>二是是否是国家</s>
<time>3069_02:16:35,967 --> 02:16:37,733</time>
<s>利盆遭受遭受这个重大损失</s>
<time>3070_02:16:38,767 --> 02:16:39,833</time>
<s>首先滥用职权</s>
<time>3071_02:16:40,533 --> 02:16:43,333</time>
<s>其主要表现一是超越职权</s>
<time>3072_02:16:43,667 --> 02:16:46,467</time>
<s>擅自决定或者处理没有权限的事项</s>
<time>3073_02:16:47,533 --> 02:16:49,267</time>
<s>第二是不正确履行职责</s>
<time>3074_02:16:49,967 --> 02:16:52,433</time>
<s>第三是故意不履行应当履行的职责</s>
<time>3075_02:16:53,133 --> 02:16:54,167</time>
<s>邢么从本案来看</s>
<time>3076_02:16:54,867 --> 02:16:56,967</time>
<s>首先从中医院的内部规定来看</s>
<time>3077_02:16:58,033 --> 02:17:00,133</time>
<s>对干重大的经费开支</s>
<time>3078_02:17:00,833 --> 02:17:03,967</time>
<s>从州中医院内部就规定要上这个</s>
<time>3079_02:17:04,667 --> 02:17:05,367</time>
<s>啊集体决策</s>
<time>3080_02:17:05,733 --> 02:17:07,133</time>
<s>并且啊</s>
<time>3081_02:17:08,167 --> 02:17:09,933</time>
<s>向有关部门进行请示汇报</s>
<time>3082_02:17:10,633 --> 02:17:11,333</time>
<s>可以看出</s>
<time>3083_02:17:11,667 --> 02:17:14,133</time>
<s>医院对经费开支是持谨慎态度</s>
<time>3084_02:17:14,467 --> 02:17:15,533</time>
<s>和严格控制的</s>
<time>3085_02:17:16,233 --> 02:17:17,267</time>
<s>但被告人韦光萍</s>
<time>3086_02:17:17,633 --> 02:17:19,733</time>
<s>王家宏在未经集体决策</s>
<time>3087_02:17:20,433 --> 02:17:21,467</time>
<s>计论决策的情况下</s>
<time>3088_02:17:22,167 --> 02:17:23,933</time>
<s>擅自决定向私人高利借贷</s>
<time>3089_02:17:24,633 --> 02:17:27,067</time>
<s>并用医院经营收入和其他收入</s>
<time>3090_02:17:27,433 --> 02:17:28,467</time>
<s>来支什高额利息</s>
<time>3091_02:17:29,533 --> 02:17:30,933</time>
<s>而这些高额利息的支出</s>
<time>3092_02:17:31,267 --> 02:17:32,667</time>
<s>同样也未经集体决策</s>
<time>3093_02:17:33,367 --> 02:17:35,133</time>
<s>显然违反7医院的内部规定</s>
<time>3094_02:17:36,167 --> 02:17:36,867</time>
<s>邢么在</s>
<time>3095_02:17:37,933 --> 02:17:38,967</time>
<s>法庭调查过程当中</s>
<time>3096_02:17:40,033 --> 02:17:40,367</time>
<s>辩护人</s>
<time>3097_02:17:40,733 --> 02:17:42,833</time>
<s>也多次提到这个上会的这个问题</s>
<time>3098_02:17:43,867 --> 02:17:45,267</time>
<s>邢么在这个</s>
<time>3099_02:17:45,967 --> 02:17:47,733</time>
<s>韦光萍本人的这个会议记录以及</s>
<time>3100_02:17:48,067 --> 02:17:49,467</time>
<s>其他班子成员的证言当中</s>
<time>3101_02:17:49,833 --> 02:17:50,533</time>
<s>都可以看出</s>
<time>3102_02:17:51,233 --> 02:17:53,667</time>
<s>没有此次会议记录的这个相关情况</s>
<time>3103_02:17:54,367 --> 02:17:56,833</time>
<s>虽然其中有三个班子成员</s>
<time>3104_02:17:57,167 --> 02:17:58,933</time>
<s>邢么称在会上通报过</s>
<time>3105_02:17:59,633 --> 02:17:59,967</time>
<s>但是我们认为</s>
<time>3106_02:18:00,333 --> 02:18:02,067</time>
<s>通报和集体计论决策</s>
<time>3107_02:18:02,433 --> 02:18:03,467</time>
<s>是两个完全不同的概念</s>
<time>3108_02:18:04,533 --> 02:18:06,633</time>
<s>邢么这个从韦光萍自己的供述当中</s>
<time>3109_02:18:06,967 --> 02:18:07,667</time>
<s>也可以看出</s>
<time>3110_02:18:08,733 --> 02:18:09,433</time>
<s>担心这个</s>
<time>3111_02:18:11,167 --> 02:18:13,267</time>
<s>这个事情啊通报之后啊</s>
<time>3112_02:18:13,967 --> 02:18:15,033</time>
<s>专题会上通不过</s>
<time>3113_02:18:15,733 --> 02:18:17,133</time>
<s>啊这个事情就做不下去</s>
<time>3114_02:18:17,467 --> 02:18:19,933</time>
<s>所以当时在这个会上只是进行了通报</s>
<time>3115_02:18:20,633 --> 02:18:22,733</time>
<s>但是我们认为这个集体计论决策</s>
<time>3116_02:18:23,433 --> 02:18:23,767</time>
<s>应当是对</s>
<time>3117_02:18:25,167 --> 02:18:25,867</time>
<s>借贷的这个</s>
<time>3118_02:18:26,567 --> 02:18:28,333</time>
<s>啊民间借贷啊是否有必要借</s>
<time>3119_02:18:29,033 --> 02:18:30,767</time>
<s>借多少期限是什么</s>
<time>3120_02:18:31,133 --> 02:18:32,867</time>
<s>给的利息能给多少</s>
<time>3121_02:18:33,567 --> 02:18:34,267</time>
<s>等等这些具体的</s>
<time>3122_02:18:34,967 --> 02:18:36,733</time>
<s>内容来进行一个计论决策</s>
<time>3123_02:18:37,433 --> 02:18:39,533</time>
<s>大家发表意见啊同意的不同意的</s>
<time>3124_02:18:40,567 --> 02:18:41,633</time>
<s>利率应该给多少</s>
<time>3125_02:18:41,967 --> 02:18:44,433</time>
<s>我们认为这个书是集体计论决策</s>
<time>3126_02:18:44,767 --> 02:18:48,267</time>
<s>而不是向会上啊通报大家啊</s>
<time>3127_02:18:49,333 --> 02:18:50,033</time>
<s>医院资金聚张</s>
<time>3128_02:18:50,367 --> 02:18:51,767</time>
<s>我们要跟这个民间融资</s>
<time>3129_02:18:52,467 --> 02:18:53,533</time>
<s>就做一个通报</s>
<time>3130_02:18:53,867 --> 02:18:55,633</time>
<s>我们认为这个是两个不同的概念</s>
<time>3131_02:18:56,667 --> 02:18:59,133</time>
<s>其实从这个国家部委和省级规定来看</s>
<time>3132_02:18:59,833 --> 02:19:00,533</time>
<s>那么也明确</s>
<time>3133_02:19:01,567 --> 02:19:02,633</time>
<s>医院对外负</s>
<time>3134_02:19:03,333 --> 02:19:06,833</time>
<s>举债需要经卫生主管部门审核</s>
<time>3135_02:19:07,167 --> 02:19:08,933</time>
<s>报同级财政部门审批</s>
<time>3136_02:19:09,967 --> 02:19:10,667</time>
<s>那么省财政</s>
<time>3137_02:19:11,367 --> 02:19:13,467</time>
<s>而省卫生厅规处的这个施金阳</s>
<time>3138_02:19:13,833 --> 02:19:15,233</time>
<s>马月光也证实</s>
<time>3139_02:19:15,933 --> 02:19:16,967</time>
<s>作为国家公立医院</s>
<time>3140_02:19:17,333 --> 02:19:19,067</time>
<s>即便是到银行贷款</s>
<time>3141_02:19:19,433 --> 02:19:22,567</time>
<s>融资等举债行为都必须要按程序审批</s>
<time>3142_02:19:22,933 --> 02:19:23,967</time>
<s>不能够撞自决定</s>
<time>3143_02:19:24,667 --> 02:19:26,433</time>
<s>更何况是向私人高利借贷</s>
<time>3144_02:19:27,133 --> 02:19:28,867</time>
<s>邢么被告人韦光萍啊</s>
<time>3145_02:19:29,233 --> 02:19:31,667</time>
<s>在这个法庭调查当中也提到过</s>
<time>3146_02:19:32,733 --> 02:19:34,467</time>
<s>那么向银行贷款啊</s>
<time>3147_02:19:34,833 --> 02:19:35,867</time>
<s>也是要需要向这个</s>
<time>3148_02:19:36,567 --> 02:19:37,967</time>
<s>啊相关部门来来批的</s>
<time>3149_02:19:39,033 --> 02:19:40,433</time>
<s>然后他们向民间借贷</s>
<time>3150_02:19:40,767 --> 02:19:42,533</time>
<s>那么就没有经过这个审批的程序</s>
<time>3151_02:19:43,233 --> 02:19:46,033</time>
<s>显然也违反了相关的这个啊规定</s>
<time>3152_02:19:47,433 --> 02:19:49,167</time>
<s>第三在2013年</s>
<time>3153_02:19:49,533 --> 02:19:51,633</time>
<s>省卫生厅在文山检查工作时</s>
<time>3154_02:19:51,967 --> 02:19:54,067</time>
<s>就已经发现州中医院存在</s>
<time>3155_02:19:54,433 --> 02:19:55,833</time>
<s>向民间高利借贷的问题</s>
<time>3156_02:19:56,533 --> 02:19:58,267</time>
<s>并向州卫生局进行7反馈</s>
<time>3157_02:19:58,633 --> 02:19:59,667</time>
<s>要求及时整改</s>
<time>3158_02:20:00,733 --> 02:20:02,133</time>
<s>邢么被告人韦光萍和王嘉宏</s>
<time>3159_02:20:02,833 --> 02:20:03,867</time>
<s>为7应什检查</s>
<time>3160_02:20:04,567 --> 02:20:07,033</time>
<s>补充7一份所谓的会议纪要</s>
<time>3161_02:20:07,367 --> 02:20:09,133</time>
<s>以及整改情况报告</s>
<time>3162_02:20:09,833 --> 02:20:10,867</time>
<s>邢么实际上</s>
<time>3163_02:20:11,933 --> 02:20:14,033</time>
<s>仍然继续向私人高利借贷</s>
<time>3164_02:20:14,367 --> 02:20:15,433</time>
<s>一直到2016年</s>
<time>3165_02:20:16,833 --> 02:20:19,267</time>
<s>视上级主管部门的整改要求与不顾</s>
<time>3166_02:20:19,967 --> 02:20:21,367</time>
<s>严重违反纪律和规定</s>
<time>3167_02:20:22,767 --> 02:20:23,467</time>
<s>因此我们认为</s>
<time>3168_02:20:24,167 --> 02:20:26,967</time>
<s>被告人韦光萍和王家宏违反相关规定</s>
<time>3169_02:20:27,333 --> 02:20:29,767</time>
<s>邢么擅自决定向私人高利借贷的行为</s>
<time>3170_02:20:30,467 --> 02:20:32,567</time>
<s>那么是典型的这个滥用职权行为</s>
<time>3171_02:20:33,967 --> 02:20:36,767</time>
<s>第二关干这个造成这个损失的问题</s>
<time>3172_02:20:37,467 --> 02:20:38,533</time>
<s>邢么在本案当中</s>
<time>3173_02:20:39,933 --> 02:20:42,367</time>
<s>被告人韦光萍和王家宏</s>
<time>3174_02:20:43,433 --> 02:20:44,133</time>
<s>邢么在共处当中</s>
<time>3175_02:20:44,467 --> 02:20:46,933</time>
<s>都明知国家法律对民间借贷</s>
<time>3176_02:20:47,967 --> 02:20:49,033</time>
<s>有这个相关的规定</s>
<time>3177_02:20:50,433 --> 02:20:51,467</time>
<s>啊出息是不超过</s>
<time>3178_02:20:51,833 --> 02:20:53,567</time>
<s>这个同期银行利率的4倍</s>
<time>3179_02:20:54,267 --> 02:20:56,367</time>
<s>邢么在民间借贷司法解释出台之后</s>
<time>3180_02:20:57,067 --> 02:20:59,533</time>
<s>啊是这个不超过这个36%</s>
<time>3181_02:21:00,933 --> 02:21:01,967</time>
<s>邢么在向私人借贷的时候</s>
<time>3182_02:21:02,667 --> 02:21:05,833</time>
<s>却给子月息3%到7%的高息</s>
<time>3183_02:21:06,867 --> 02:21:08,967</time>
<s>从鉴定意见的分析也可以看得出来</s>
<time>3184_02:21:10,033 --> 02:21:11,767</time>
<s>州中医院的高息借贷</s>
<time>3185_02:21:12,133 --> 02:21:14,567</time>
<s>邢么除7使用后期借款</s>
<time>3186_02:21:14,933 --> 02:21:15,967</time>
<s>偿还前期本息</s>
<time>3187_02:21:16,333 --> 02:21:18,767</time>
<s>这种拆东墙补西墙的这种方式之外</s>
<time>3188_02:21:19,833 --> 02:21:22,967</time>
<s>必然要挤占医院的正常经营收入</s>
<time>3189_02:21:23,667 --> 02:21:25,067</time>
<s>根据医院的相关规定</s>
<time>3190_02:21:26,133 --> 02:21:28,233</time>
<s>医院的正常经营收入是不得</s>
<time>3191_02:21:28,933 --> 02:21:29,633</time>
<s>擅自使用的</s>
<time>3192_02:21:30,333 --> 02:21:32,767</time>
<s>应当纳入医院发展基金</s>
<time>3193_02:21:33,833 --> 02:21:34,167</time>
<s>也就是说</s>
<time>3194_02:21:35,233 --> 02:21:36,633</time>
<s>当年的这个医院的盈余</s>
<time>3195_02:21:37,667 --> 02:21:38,367</time>
<s>即便有盈余</s>
<time>3196_02:21:39,067 --> 02:21:40,467</time>
<s>除开支什</s>
<time>3197_02:21:41,533 --> 02:21:42,567</time>
<s>职工工资福利之外</s>
<time>3198_02:21:43,267 --> 02:21:45,033</time>
<s>啊医院的这个发展建设之外</s>
<time>3199_02:21:45,733 --> 02:21:48,533</time>
<s>邢么是必须存入到这个发展基全当中</s>
<time>3200_02:21:49,233 --> 02:21:50,967</time>
<s>用干医院的正常经营和发展</s>
<time>3201_02:21:51,667 --> 02:21:53,433</time>
<s>支什职工的工资和福利</s>
<time>3202_02:21:54,133 --> 02:21:55,167</time>
<s>但却被韦光萍</s>
<time>3203_02:21:55,867 --> 02:21:59,033</time>
<s>王家宏用来支什了高额的利息给私人</s>
<time>3204_02:22:00,067 --> 02:22:00,767</time>
<s>这就相当于</s>
<time>3205_02:22:01,133 --> 02:22:03,233</time>
<s>将国有资产以借贷什息的方式</s>
<time>3206_02:22:04,267 --> 02:22:05,667</time>
<s>啊出现了流失</s>
<time>3207_02:22:06,367 --> 02:22:09,167</time>
<s>超过法律规定736%的利息部分</s>
<time>3208_02:22:09,533 --> 02:22:11,967</time>
<s>就给国家造成7值接经济的损失</s>
<time>3209_02:22:13,033 --> 02:22:13,733</time>
<s>邢么我们来看</s>
<time>3210_02:22:15,133 --> 02:22:16,167</time>
<s>州中医院向民间借贷</s>
<time>3211_02:22:16,533 --> 02:22:18,967</time>
<s>可以3%到7%的高额利息</s>
<time>3212_02:22:20,033 --> 02:22:22,133</time>
<s>试问何种生产经营</s>
<time>3213_02:22:23,167 --> 02:22:25,633</time>
<s>能够达到年均36%</s>
<time>3214_02:22:25,967 --> 02:22:28,767</time>
<s>甚至更高的这个经营收入和利润</s>
<time>3215_02:22:30,167 --> 02:22:31,933</time>
<s>邢么医院的正常经营利润</s>
<time>3216_02:22:32,267 --> 02:22:34,733</time>
<s>如何偿还如此高的这个借款利息</s>
<time>3217_02:22:36,133 --> 02:22:36,833</time>
<s>邢么从近年来</s>
<time>3218_02:22:37,167 --> 02:22:39,267</time>
<s>文山发生的多起非法集资案件</s>
<time>3219_02:22:39,633 --> 02:22:40,333</time>
<s>我们也可以看得出来</s>
<time>3220_02:22:41,367 --> 02:22:42,767</time>
<s>这种借新还旧的债务</s>
<time>3221_02:22:43,133 --> 02:22:44,533</time>
<s>雪球只会越滚越大</s>
