<time>1101_00:42:28,367 --> 00:42:29,433</time>
<s>高矮胖瘦什么样的人都有</s>
<time>1102_00:42:29,767 --> 00:42:31,533</time>
<s>前面有一个被辩人还长得是很高</s>
<time>1103_00:42:31,867 --> 00:42:33,267</time>
<s>至少要1米81米9</s>
<time>1104_00:42:33,633 --> 00:42:36,067</time>
<s>他不符合辨认的混杂性条件</s>
<time>1105_00:42:36,767 --> 00:42:38,867</time>
<s>那么这样的证据我们拿来</s>
<time>1106_00:42:39,233 --> 00:42:40,633</time>
<s>就按照公诉人第一轮公诉意见</s>
<time>1107_00:42:40,967 --> 00:42:42,033</time>
<s>说的证据已经完整了</s>
<time>1108_00:42:42,367 --> 00:42:44,133</time>
<s>这些证据都能够相互印证了</s>
<time>1109_00:42:44,467 --> 00:42:45,167</time>
<s>辩护人认为啊</s>
<time>1110_00:42:45,533 --> 00:42:46,567</time>
<s>现有的证据</s>
<time>1111_00:42:46,933 --> 00:42:47,267</time>
<s>远远</s>
<time>1112_00:42:47,633 --> 00:42:48,333</time>
<s>没有达到</s>
<time>1113_00:42:48,667 --> 00:42:50,067</time>
<s>能够证明说白**</s>
<time>1114_00:42:50,433 --> 00:42:51,833</time>
<s>就是当天殿打的那个人</s>
<time>1115_00:42:52,533 --> 00:42:53,567</time>
<s>的这样的一个程度</s>
<time>1116_00:42:53,933 --> 00:42:57,433</time>
<s>更不可能排除掉说有其他人在的可能</s>
<time>1117_00:42:58,133 --> 00:42:59,533</time>
<s>白刚才在自己自我辩护的时候</s>
<time>1118_00:42:59,867 --> 00:43:00,233</time>
<s>也提到了一点</s>
<time>1119_00:43:00,567 --> 00:43:02,333</time>
<s>他说那天穿什么样的衣服人都有</s>
<time>1120_00:43:02,667 --> 00:43:04,067</time>
<s>我们从现场监控也可以看到</s>
<time>1121_00:43:04,433 --> 00:43:05,467</time>
<s>当天很混乱</s>
<time>1122_00:43:05,833 --> 00:43:07,933</time>
<s>除了他们几个人以外圃着车有好多人</s>
<time>1123_00:43:08,633 --> 00:43:10,367</time>
<s>那么有没有可能围着车的人里面</s>
<time>1124_00:43:10,733 --> 00:43:12,833</time>
<s>不属于我们本案指控材料里面的</s>
<time>1125_00:43:13,167 --> 00:43:13,533</time>
<s>任何一人</s>
<time>1126_00:43:13,867 --> 00:43:14,933</time>
<s>当然是有这种可能的</s>
<time>1127_00:43:15,267 --> 00:43:17,733</time>
<s>这就是我们说的无法排除合理怀疑</s>
<time>1128_00:43:18,067 --> 00:43:19,467</time>
<s>本案现有证据得出的结论</s>
<time>1129_00:43:19,833 --> 00:43:20,533</time>
<s>不具有唯一性</s>
<time>1130_00:43:21,233 --> 00:43:24,033</time>
<s>所以不管是从正反两个方面辩护人认为</s>
<time>1131_00:43:24,367 --> 00:43:25,767</time>
<s>本案的证据都没有达到邢事诉讼法</s>
<time>1132_00:43:26,133 --> 00:43:27,167</time>
<s>法定的证明标准一</s>
<time>1133_00:43:27,867 --> 00:43:30,667</time>
<s>这个案子在审查起诉过程当中</s>
<time>1134_00:43:31,367 --> 00:43:33,467</time>
<s>关于定罪的证据就发生了变化</s>
<time>1135_00:43:34,867 --> 00:43:35,933</time>
<s>但是如果被告人</s>
<time>1136_00:43:36,267 --> 00:43:38,367</time>
<s>当时的犯罪嫌疑人如果可以认罪的话</s>
<time>1137_00:43:38,733 --> 00:43:40,833</time>
<s>我们当然可以不变更强制措施</s>
<time>1138_00:43:41,867 --> 00:43:44,333</time>
<s>我们在对被告人白**进行讯问以后</s>
<time>1139_00:43:44,667 --> 00:43:46,067</time>
<s>他仍然坚持包括电话</s>
<time>1140_00:43:47,467 --> 00:43:50,267</time>
<s>核实确实是没有认错的态度</s>
<time>1141_00:43:50,633 --> 00:43:52,033</time>
<s>根据刑诉法来讲</s>
<time>1142_00:43:52,733 --> 00:43:54,133</time>
<s>就不符合取保条件</s>
<time>1143_00:43:55,167 --> 00:43:57,633</time>
<s>而且就这个问题辩护人没必要</s>
<time>1144_00:43:58,333 --> 00:43:59,033</time>
<s>过多纠结</s>
<time>1145_00:44:00,433 --> 00:44:02,167</time>
<s>其他的没有了</s>
<time>1146_00:44:03,567 --> 00:44:04,267</time>
<s>被告人有新的意见一</s>
<time>1147_00:44:04,967 --> 00:44:05,667</time>
<s>新的意见没有</s>
<time>1148_00:44:06,033 --> 00:44:06,733</time>
<s>辩护人</s>
<time>1149_00:44:07,067 --> 00:44:08,133</time>
<s>公诉人刚才说</s>
<time>1150_00:44:08,833 --> 00:44:10,567</time>
<s>辩护人在反复纠结</s>
<time>1151_00:44:10,933 --> 00:44:12,333</time>
<s>公诉人在对</s>
<time>1152_00:44:12,667 --> 00:44:15,133</time>
<s>白**的强制措施的这个</s>
<time>1153_00:44:15,467 --> 00:44:16,533</time>
<s>实施的问题上</s>
<time>1154_00:44:16,867 --> 00:44:18,633</time>
<s>是否违法的问题</s>
<time>1155_00:44:19,333 --> 00:44:21,433</time>
<s>这个问题我觉得不是纠不纠结的问题</s>
<time>1156_00:44:21,767 --> 00:44:23,167</time>
<s>它是一个程序合法性的问题</s>
<time>1157_00:44:23,533 --> 00:44:24,567</time>
<s>当然我也这个</s>
<time>1158_00:44:24,933 --> 00:44:26,667</time>
<s>认可刚才公诉人一个说法</s>
<time>1159_00:44:27,033 --> 00:44:27,733</time>
<s>说如果说啊</s>
<time>1160_00:44:28,067 --> 00:44:30,167</time>
<s>可能判处3年以上有期徒刑的案件</s>
<time>1161_00:44:30,533 --> 00:44:31,933</time>
<s>那么并且被告人不认罪的</s>
<time>1162_00:44:32,267 --> 00:44:33,667</time>
<s>通常情况下是不能取保的</s>
<time>1163_00:44:34,733 --> 00:44:36,833</time>
<s>白**自始至终没有认过罪</s>
<time>1164_00:44:37,533 --> 00:44:39,633</time>
<s>他到检察院你们给他办取保的时候</s>
<time>1165_00:44:39,967 --> 00:44:40,667</time>
<s>他也没有认过罪</s>
<time>1166_00:44:41,033 --> 00:44:42,767</time>
<s>他不存在说我前面认罪了</s>
<time>1167_00:44:43,133 --> 00:44:45,233</time>
<s>我办了取保我又翻供不认罪的情况</s>
<time>1168_00:44:45,567 --> 00:44:47,667</time>
<s>那么我刚才在辩论说我已经请</s>
<time>1169_00:44:48,367 --> 00:44:49,433</time>
<s>公诉人能够回应一下</s>
<time>1170_00:44:49,767 --> 00:44:52,233</time>
<s>你这七天哪些重大证据发生变化了</s>
<time>1171_00:44:52,567 --> 00:44:54,667</time>
<s>但是我仔细听还是没有听到这种回应</s>
<time>1172_00:44:55,033 --> 00:44:56,433</time>
<s>那么两轮都没有回应</s>
<time>1173_00:44:56,767 --> 00:44:57,833</time>
<s>辩护人只能认为</s>
<time>1174_00:44:58,167 --> 00:44:59,567</time>
<s>公诉人可能也无法解释</s>
<time>1175_00:44:59,933 --> 00:45:01,667</time>
<s>因为你举证的时候也没有证明这一点</s>
<time>1176_00:45:02,033 --> 00:45:03,433</time>
<s>那么这只能证明什公</s>
<time>1177_00:45:03,767 --> 00:45:04,467</time>
<s>只能证明</s>
<time>1178_00:45:04,833 --> 00:45:07,633</time>
<s>对白**在审查起诉阶段的强制措施</s>
<time>1179_00:45:07,967 --> 00:45:09,733</time>
<s>也是程序违法的没有了</s>
<time>1180_00:45:11,467 --> 00:45:13,567</time>
<s>好辩论阶段结束啊</s>
<time>1181_00:45:14,633 --> 00:45:15,667</time>
<s>被告人白**</s>
<time>1182_00:45:16,367 --> 00:45:18,133</time>
<s>你有最后陈述的权利</s>
<time>1183_00:45:18,467 --> 00:45:20,233</time>
<s>尊敬的审判长审判员</s>
<time>1184_00:45:21,267 --> 00:45:21,967</time>
<s>公人</s>
<time>1185_00:45:23,367 --> 00:45:25,467</time>
<s>此案过去五年多了对方</s>
<time>1186_00:45:26,167 --> 00:45:28,967</time>
<s>白*你尽量念得清楚一点</s>
<time>1187_00:45:30,033 --> 00:45:31,433</time>
<s>我这个嗓子不行</s>
<time>1188_00:45:31,767 --> 00:45:33,867</time>
<s>你用不用喝点水我给你要点水也可以</s>
<time>1189_00:45:34,233 --> 00:45:34,933</time>
<s>不用不用</s>
<time>1190_00:45:35,633 --> 00:45:37,733</time>
<s>那你尽量发音准确一点</s>
<time>1191_00:45:38,067 --> 00:45:38,767</time>
<s>以便大家都能听到啊</s>
<time>1192_00:45:39,133 --> 00:45:39,833</time>
<s>好好好</s>
<time>1193_00:45:40,533 --> 00:45:42,267</time>
<s>此案过去五年多了</s>
<time>1194_00:45:42,967 --> 00:45:44,367</time>
<s>对方一直</s>
<time>1195_00:45:45,067 --> 00:45:45,767</time>
<s>谤告我</s>
<time>1196_00:45:46,833 --> 00:45:47,867</time>
<s>我和他素不相识</s>
<time>1197_00:45:48,567 --> 00:45:49,267</time>
<s>从来不认得</s>
<time>1198_00:45:49,633 --> 00:45:50,333</time>
<s>跟他也无冤无仇</s>
<time>1199_00:45:51,033 --> 00:45:52,067</time>
<s>我不可能就是</s>
<time>1200_00:45:53,133 --> 00:45:54,167</time>
<s>过去上来就打他</s>
<time>1201_00:45:54,867 --> 00:45:55,933</time>
<s>我跟他也没优</s>
<time>1202_00:45:57,333 --> 00:45:58,733</time>
<s>我希望审判长对此案</s>
<time>1203_00:46:01,867 --> 00:46:02,933</time>
<s>查明真相</s>
<time>1204_00:46:04,667 --> 00:46:05,367</time>
<s>还我清白</s>
<time>1205_00:46:06,433 --> 00:46:07,833</time>
<s>怎么样大家看的还过瘾吗</s>
<time>1206_00:46:08,167 --> 00:46:09,933</time>
<s>有这样的律师出现在法庭上</s>
<time>1207_00:46:10,267 --> 00:46:11,667</time>
<s>对公诉人是个很大的挑战</s>
<time>1208_00:46:12,367 --> 00:46:14,133</time>
<s>虽然这场庭审的公诉人很年轻</s>
<time>1209_00:46:14,467 --> 00:46:15,867</time>
<s>但面对这样强大的对手</s>
<time>1210_00:46:16,567 --> 00:46:17,967</time>
<s>已经表现非常不错了</s>
<time>1211_00:46:18,667 --> 00:46:20,067</time>
<s>对法官也是个很大的挑战呀</s>
<time>1212_00:46:20,767 --> 00:46:22,533</time>
<s>对书记员那就是更大的挑战了</s>
<time>1213_00:46:23,233 --> 00:46:25,333</time>
<s>辩护人两次强行变慢语速笑死我了</s>
<time>1214_00:46:25,667 --> 00:46:26,733</time>
<s>真是绷不住啊</s>
<time>1215_00:46:27,433 --> 00:46:29,533</time>
<s>由于今天这场庭审判决还没有出来</s>
<time>1216_00:46:29,867 --> 00:46:32,333</time>
<s>所以关于案件本身我就不多说了</s>
<time>1217_00:46:33,033 --> 00:46:33,733</time>
<s>这个案子的最终判决</s>
<time>1218_00:46:34,067 --> 00:46:36,167</time>
<s>对法院也应该是个很大的挑战</s>
<time>1219_00:46:36,867 --> 00:46:38,967</time>
<s>给大家说一说这名强悍的律师吧</s>
<time>1220_00:46:39,333 --> 00:46:40,367</time>
<s>我看她晒朋友圈啊</s>
<time>1221_00:46:40,733 --> 00:46:42,133</time>
<s>被客户描述为女老虎</s>
<time>1222_00:46:42,833 --> 00:46:43,533</time>
<s>她叫李扬</s>
<time>1223_00:46:43,867 --> 00:46:44,933</time>
<s>人大法学硕士</s>
<time>1224_00:46:45,633 --> 00:46:46,667</time>
<s>北大的法学博士</s>
<time>1225_00:46:47,367 --> 00:46:49,133</time>
<s>社科院法学研究所的博土后</s>
<time>1226_00:46:49,833 --> 00:46:50,867</time>
<s>中国民族大学的教授</s>
<time>1227_00:46:51,567 --> 00:46:53,333</time>
<s>是非常著名的刑事辩护律师</s>
<time>1228_00:46:54,367 --> 00:46:55,767</time>
<s>无罪辩护啊是她的强项</s>
<time>1229_00:46:56,133 --> 00:46:58,933</time>
<s>2021年全国十大无罪案例的第一个案子</s>
<time>1230_00:46:59,267 --> 00:46:59,967</time>
<s>就是她办的</s>
<time>1231_00:47:00,667 --> 00:47:01,367</time>
<s>王海泉案</s>
<time>1232_00:47:01,733 --> 00:47:02,767</time>
<s>经历了一审</s>
<time>1233_00:47:03,133 --> 00:47:04,167</time>
<s>发回重审</s>
<time>1234_00:47:04,533 --> 00:47:06,267</time>
<s>重一审二审等程序</s>
<time>1235_00:47:06,967 --> 00:47:08,733</time>
<s>最终改判为无罪的一个案子</s>
<time>1236_00:47:09,067 --> 00:47:09,767</time>
<s>不是这个行业的同学</s>
<time>1237_00:47:10,133 --> 00:47:11,533</time>
<s>可能不太能够体会到</s>
<time>1238_00:47:11,867 --> 00:47:13,267</time>
<s>这是多么高难度的一个事情</s>
<time>1239_00:47:13,967 --> 00:47:14,333</time>
<s>就这么说吧</s>
<time>1240_00:47:15,033 --> 00:47:17,133</time>
<s>有很多刑事律师终其一生</s>
<time>1241_00:47:17,467 --> 00:47:19,233</time>
<s>可能都完不成一个无罪辩护的案例</s>
<time>1242_00:47:19,933 --> 00:47:20,967</time>
<s>好了本次解说就到这几</s>
<time>1243_00:47:21,333 --> 00:47:22,367</time>
<s>祝大家节日快乐再见</s>
